1999 FROM
ANECDOTAL MATERIALS of The JOURNALS OF BEN WILLIAMS AND OTHER ANALECTAL SOURCES
JANUARY
1 January 1999
Friday
Well it’s a new year and the
last one from the 20th Century. That seems so weird that I have lived long
enough to see the turn of the century. Well that is if I make it through this
year. I am still tired from being out so late for First Night although it was
fun.
I am a 47 years old middle aged balding fat Gay man with
a beard. My glory days are way behind me. I have been an elementary school
teacher in Davis County School District now for ten years, first at Sunset
Elementary but mostly at Orchard in North Salt Lake. I teach 5th Grade but want to
change grades just to get away from Elaine Day who passive aggressively tries
to dominate 5th grade. I am so tired of doing Christmas Pageants to
make her look good. Hal Olsen in 4th Grade is retiring this year so
hopefully Pam Park our principal will let me transfer. I am sure she will.
Enough of that as school starts back up on Monday.
Mike Romero and I live at 1633 Fernleaf street in Salt
Lake City near the Rose Park golf course and not far from I-215. At one time
our house in the Reliance tract out here was the only one finished and you
could see out Christmas lights from the freeway. Now the subdivision is filled
in and Ivory Homes is building all around us so most of the horse property is
disappearing.
We have four dogs and a cat named Billy. Oscar is our
oldest Schnauzer that we have had for 3 years now. He’s probably about 9 or 10
years old. Priscilla is a duashund mix and we got her as a puppy from Rawlins and
she is about 4 years old now. The two other schnauzers are Saffy and Smokey.
They are brother and sister but from different litters.
Mike and I live in different parts of the house now with
his bedroom upstairs and mine down stairs in the basement that I finished
mostly. Our friend Rich Butler helped me put in a false ceiling and our
neighbor Randy Gile helped me with the sheetrock. Mike didn’t help at all.
Well I don’t know what the year will bring. Maybe Mike
and I will break up. That makes me really sad as I still love him but I know
he’s not in love with me.
I feel rather isolated way out here far from the city and
have lost contact with most of my old friends and I have nothing to do with the
Gay community anymore. I am just a relic from a different time but at least so
far I have survived AIDS. I guess that is something I suppose.
There’s a full moon tonight and we will have a blue moon
at the end of the month. It was a pretty day after the rain we had yesterday
evening. It was clear and about 40 degrees.
I read in the
obituaries that Salt Lake Tribune history writer Harold Schlinder died last
December 28. I liked a lot of his works but did not like his glorifying Porter
Rockwell who was nothing more than a psychopathic serial killer for Joseph
Smith and Brigham Young.
3 January 1999
Sunday
Mike and I went to the Tower
Theater and saw John Water’s latest movie Pecker. It wasn’t as good as some of
his others I think. We did enjoy South Park’s Orgasmo about a Mormon Missionary
who becomes a porn star! Ha! The theater was packed.
I read in the Sunday paper Tom
Barberi’s predictions for 1999 and one was that Utah Legislature would outlaw
Gay and Lesbian teachers from driving through Draper with a cell phone in the
ear and a six pack in the trunk! “ ha!
4 January 1999 Monday
I think the kids were glad to
see me and be back in school. I think Christmas takes a lot out of them. I saw
that the Italian-American actor who portrayed Native American Iron Eyes Cody died
today at the age of 94. He was the face of commercials in the 1970s about
environmentalism to Keep America Beautiful.
6 January 1999
Wednesday
It was really smoggy today
with a strong inversion so it was an indoor recess all day.
I read that the mother of one
of the men Russell Henderson charged in the death of Matthew Shepard died of
exposure after staggering out of a downtown bar. Cindy Thompson Dixon was found
dead outside of Laramie. The police questioned her husband who had a history of
spousal abuse found no evidence of foul
play. Death was from hypothermia.
8 January 1999
Friday
The head of the Utah State
Adoption agency wants to ban Gay couples from adopting and other unmarried
couples. Sounds fair until the hypocrites say that Gays can’t marry not because
they don’t want to.
9 January 1999
Saturday
Happy birthday John Francis
Cunningham where ever you may be.
11 January 1999
Monday
There are pink flyers posted
all over downtown stating that Rocky Anderson is a “flunky” of the Gay movement. Some
believe Merrill Cook is behind it but he denies it.
18 January Monday
There’s no school today
because of Martin Luther King’s birthday. It’s the first day of the new
legislature and the state’s first Gay legislator, Jackie Biskupski was sworn in
which pissed off Gayle Ruzicka who said, “It’s too bad we don’t have a whole
army of legislators who say we’re not going to allow a lawmaker.”
19 January 1999
Tuesday
It’s the end of the first half
of the school year and I sent home
grades today. I should have last Friday but
the computers were down at the District so I couldn’t access them. Today is
dad’s 74th birthday. Mom said they celebrated it at the Senior
Center last Sunday.
22 January 1999
Friday
Pope John Paul said no to Gay
marriages “lamenting spread of deteriororation of the natural and religious
sense of marriage.” He doesn’t want Gay
couples to benefit form pensions and housing either.”
23 January Saturday
The board of the Child and
Family Services voted 7-2 to ban unmarried
couples and Gay and Lesbians partners from adopting foster children. Board
chair Scott Clark “blasted gay parents for exposing their children to gender
confusion!” Gayle Ruzicka like Madam Defarge
was “stitching a needlepoint project.” Robert Austin’s partner Bradley Weischedel
spoke at the board stating that they had adopted a 9 year old boy through
private means.
24 January 1999
Sunday
I saw a want ad in the Tribune
for a manager for the Stonewall Coffee shop in the “New Gay and Lesbian
Community Center.” The starting salary
is $17,000 which more than any of the directors received at the old Utah
Stonewall Center which was the only paid position there.
31 January 1999
Sunday
Once in a Blue Moon. It’s the
second full moon this month and I kept singing Nanci Griffiths song in my head.
I am so glad this long month is over. We
didn’t have much snow this month and wasn’t
FEBRUARY
1 February 1999
Monday
AIDS ANIMAL ORIGINS: People
Got AIDS From Chimps, Scientists
Believe- Scientists believe they have solved the lingering mystery of where the
AIDS virus came from: chimps. In a
presentation Sunday, researchers from the University of Alabama at Birmingham
said they have convincing proof that the virus has spread from chimpanzees to
people in Africa on at least three separate occasions. One of these cross-species transmissions was
the start of the epidemic that now
infects about 35 million people worldwide.
Chimps, which probably have carried the virus for hundreds of thousands
of years, apparently do not get sick from it. Figuring out why could be
important. "This is excellent science with biological and virological
importance. If we understood how the chimp has dealt with this infection over
time, that could have implications for human medicine," said Kevin DeCock,
an AIDS expert at the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in Atlanta. While chimps have long been
suspected as the source, "there have been a lot of loose ends that made
people uncomfortable drawing that conclusion," said Beatrice Hahn. Hahn
said her team nailed down the connection by analyzing frozen tissue saved from
a chimp named Marilyn who died 14 years ago (1985). The chimp version of the AIDS virus -- the
microbe now thought to be the grandfather of HIV -- is called SIVcpz. It is
extremely rare among chimps in U.S. lab colonies, apparently because these
animals are removed from the wild as babies and so are never exposed to the
virus sexually. Until recently, SIVcpz had been isolated only three times. The
fourth turned up when a colleague cleaning out a lab freezer ran across Marilyn's specimens and sent them to
Hahn. Her team was able to perform various kinds of genetic analyses that were
unavailable when the chimp died. Then the Alabama team used molecular-analysis
techniques to study all four examples of the virus. They found that three of
the four were extremely similar genetically to the human AIDS virus. They
included one gene, called vpu, that also is part of HIV but not of other
AIDS-like viruses that infect monkeys.
All three samples came from Pan troglodytes troglodytes, which is one of
the four subspecies of chimp in Africa. These animals live in Cameroon,
Equatorial Guinea, Congo and Central African Republic, the region where AIDS is
thought to have started. The fourth sample, much less like HIV, came from
another subspecies of chimp that is native to East Africa. Among humans, there are three major groups
of HIV, code-named M, N and O. M is the variety that has spread around the
world, while N and O are seen only in west-central Africa. The natural habitat
of Pan troglodytes troglodytes exactly overlaps the area where these three
groups were first recognized. The researchers believe that each group arose
from a separate chimp-to-human transmission of SIVcpz. "We conclude that this subspecies is
the natural host and reservoir for HIV-1," the AIDS virus, said Hahn,
whose work also is being published in
this week's issue of the journal Nature.
She said a French team, headed by Phillippe Mauclere of the Pasteur
Institute, recently found three more chimps infected with SIVcpz at a game
sanctuary in Cameroon. One sample has been genetically analyzed and it, too,
closely resembles HIV. ;"That
nails it," said Hahn. "The only possible criticism is that we had
made too much out of four animals." BY DANIEL Q. HANEY THE ASSOCIATED
PRESS CHICAGO –
2 February 1999
Tuesday
Hate-crimes legislation that
would provide specific protection for gays, lesbians, abortion clinics and
other groups and enhance penalties is already drawing contentious debate on
Capitol Hill. At a hearing Tuesday before the Senate Judiciary Committee, both
proponents and opponents of a proposed hate crimes law packed the room to hear
and voice their own views on SB34, which outlines categories of people and
institutions that would receive protection under the current law. Sponsoring
Sen. Pete Suazo, D-Salt Lake, said the hate crimes statute passed in 1992 is
inadequate because it was watered downed by the same opposition it faced
Tuesday. "Why are we even considering something like this?" asked
Gayle Ruzicka, head of the conservative Eagle Forum, an opponent to the bill.
"All people deserve to be protected equally." She said Utah law
should not protect "illegal and immoral behavior" such as sexual
orientation under the proposed bill. But Jeanetta Williams, president of the Salt
Lake branch of the NAACP, said Utah needs to stop denying it has a hate crimes
problem. "It is a big problem here in Utah when we have to come back and
discuss this bill. There shouldn't even be an argument." The committee did
not vote on the bill as time ran out before all those scheduled to testify
could speak. The bill would protect people against hate crimes on the basis of
race, religion, national origin, color, gender, sexual orientation, ethnicity
or mental or physical disabilities. Any misdemeanor crime such as assault,
telephone harassment or vandalism becomes a third-degree felony if motivated on
the basis of these categories. In addition, the bill also protects religious
institutions, psychiatric hospitals, abortion clinics and health-care
providers. The bill also provides for sentencing enhancements if the crime is
already a felony. For example, a judge would have the discretion to impose a
minimum term of between five-to-eight years in prison if the person is
convicted of a crime that is a first-degree felony and proven to be hate crime.
"These acts of terrorism are taking place. These are crimes we must
vigorously prosecute," Suazo said. "They are the antithesis of the
values that define us as a nation and a state. They have nothing to do with
equality, freedom or respect." Prosecutors have complained that Utah's
current hate crime law is difficult to prosecute because it fails to define
protected categories and it requires proof that the accused meant to intimidate
or terrorize. Suazo's bill deletes the language of intimidate or terrorize.
Paul Boyden with the Statewide Association of Prosecutors said after the
hearing that the proposal addresses some of the problems with the current law,
although his group has not taken position.
4 February 1999
Thursday
Ben Fulton City Weekly GAY COMMUNITY CENTER UTAH COFFEE
SHOP OR COMMUNITY CENTER? Coffee or Community? Gay & Lesbian Center
Searches for a Course
After months
of planning, fund raising, networking and construction, Salt Lake City’s
Stonewall Center has been successfully reincarnated into the Gay & Lesbian
Community Center. It’s a small, charming, two-story building with hardwood
floors and a library. Its doors have been open wide since October, but has it
sacrificed a vision for the gay community in favor of a business- like drive to
increase operating funds? That’s the feeling of some in the community, and the
opinion of two former Center administrators.
There are
also charges that the tone of the Center, whose Operating Board comprises
several successful business owners, has become elitist, demonstrating little
concern for more blue-collar members of the community. Some who've resigned
their administrative positions say programs aren't receiving enough attention.
Others disagree.
Part and
parcel of any new organization, or the sign of final decisions sure to direct
the Center’s future? All that remains to be seen, but with the resignation of
its executive director and a small row over the balance sheet of the Center’s
coffee shop, Stonewall Coffee, there have been plenty of tremors. Oddly, the
center of those small quakes has been Stonewall Coffee.
Even before
the Center opened, everyone agreed that a coffee shop would act as a
complementary social magnet—an ideal meeting place. That it has, say Stonewall
Coffee supporters. But critics contend the small bistro has taken center stage,
at the expense of actively forming programs that would empower Salt Lake City’s
gay and lesbian community.
Complicating
matters, critics say, is the fact that many people who donated money to the
coffee shop’s initial operations also sit on the Center’s Operating Board. So,
is the end result a gay and lesbian community center inside a Coffee Shop, or a
coffee shop inside a Gay and Lesbian Community Center? Naturally, the answer
depends on whom you ask.
“The vision of some board members is that it
would be a coffee shop first and foremost to make profit so that it would
sustain the operation of the building. But when you talked to them about goals
beyond that they had no ideas. I don’t want to bad-mouth the Center. I miss it
very much. But I was hired to do a job, and I was not allowed to do a job,”
said Monique Predovitch, who resigned her position as executive director just
over a month ago. “It was a division of a business downstairs and a non-profit
community center upstairs. The business won out.”
Alan Ahtow,
who, as interim director, kept the Center alive on the web while a building
site was scouted, expressed similar feelings. Like Predovitch, he’s careful not
to frame his differences with the Center’s current board in terms of who’s
right and who’s wrong. Rather, it’s an issue of how the Center can best serve
the community, Ahtow says. He left his positions as board member and
Predovitch’s assistant when it became apparent that programs were being
overlooked for the coffee shop.
“I think it
would be unfortunate for the opportunity we have as a community, and for the
Center’s potential, if it just became a place to hang out and drink coffee,”
Ahtow said. “I think the idea of a coffee shop was sound, but the execution
wasn’t what people imagined. When you have people in the position of donating
money to the center who are also on the board there are problems you encounter.
It’s easy to say something like, ‘If you don’t do what I want you’re not going
to get my money or my service or my time.’
From my own observation, I think there were
instances where people felt uncomfortable or intimidated. It’s not necessarily
a healthy environment to operate in. “I’m not saying people didn’t have the
best intentions. But I do think there was a lot of posturing, a lot of ego and
a lot of comments fell on deaf ears,” Ahtow said.
Michelle
Turpin, a local tax attorney and board member who donated money toward
Stonewall Coffee’s initial expenses, contends there’s been no let-up in
programs since the Center opened.
The board was
fast to assign a new interim director, Doug Wortham, and the Center’s schedule
is full with meetings and workshops, she said. True, the coffee shop might have
received more than its share of attention upon opening, but it’s long since
lost its status as the center of attention. Turpin sees no conflict of interest
in her roles as board member and donator to the Center. “All I have to say is,
‘Where’s the conflict?’ I have nothing to gain financially. I’m doing this
because I have a bleeding heart for gay rights,” Turpin said. “By nature,
anybody who puts time or money into an organization is going to want to see it
succeed.”
Criticism is
no problem for Turpin. For perspective, she remembers the example of Lori Jean,
the former director of the Los Angeles Gay and Lesbian Center who took its
annual budget from $3 million to $24 million.
“She caught flak, but gained respect in the end,” Turpin said. “We have
successful business people on the board so that we can hopefully run a tight
ship. It has to be run like a business or it’s not going to make it.”
Senate committee rejects
changes in hate-crime bill A bill proposing to reform Utah's hate-crime law
died a sudden death Thursday after a party-line vote of 4-2 in the Senate
Judiciary Committee. Despite urging by the NAACP, the Utah Sentencing Commission
and the Episcopalian Diocese, Sen. Pete Suazo's SB34 was killed in committee.
Suazo said he has no plans to resurrect it this session. The bill provided
criminal penalty enhancements for specific categories of people and
institutions if victimized by a crime. Those categories -- particularly sexual
orientation -- raised the ire of groups like Utah Eagle Forum, the America
Forever Foundation and Concerned Women For America. Democrat Suazo and Sen.
Mike Dmitrich, D-Price, endorsed the bill, which also extended protection to
institutions like churches and abortion clinics. Republican senators Terry
Spencer, John Valentine, Lyle Hillyard and Parley Hellewell voted against it.
The bill made certain misdemeanors a third-degree felony if prosecutors could
prove the crimes were motivated by hate. Felonies also were subject to
sentencing enhancements. Prosecutors have complained Utah's current law is too
vague and difficult to apply because it fails to include categories of
protected classes.
The Utah Hate Crimes
Amendments bill (1SSB34) was defeated on Feb. 4
by a vote of 4 to 2 in a meeting of the state Senate Standing Committee
on Judiciary at the state Capitol Building in Salt Lake City. The bill would
have amended the state hate-crimes penalties and statistics laws by expanding
the protected categories and redefining a hate crime. State Sen. Pete Suazo,
D-Salt Lake City, and various minority leaders said that the laws needed to be
updated to reflect the relevant laws and court rulings of other states, and
make the Utah penalties law enforceable. He said that it hasn't been used by
state courts because many judges and prosecutors believe it's too vague. You
may tell the committee members how you feel about their votes about the bill by
sending an electronic-mail message to each of them: Republican Chair Sen. Terry
Spencer voted "no. Republican Sen. Parley G. Hellewell voted
"no" Republican Sen. Lyle W. Hillyard voted "no" Republican
Sen. John L. Valentine voted "no"
Democratic Co-Sponsor Sen. Mike Dmitrich voted "yes"
Democratic Sponsor Sen. Pete Suazo voted "yes". Reported by David
Nelson Salt Lake City
5 February 1999
Friday
I read that the Legislators
shot down Pete Suazo’s Hate Crime Bill that would have included Gay people. David
Thometz was quoted a lot in a Tribune article. I guess he is head of GLUD now
that David Nelson no loner is. I remember when David was Bobbie Smith’s
roommate over on Del Mar Court.
7 February 1999
Sunday
Stan Penfold has been named
acting executive director of the Utah AIDS Foundation, a non-profit
organization dedicated to preventing the spread of HIV and ensuring
compassionate delivery of services to people affected by HIV/AIDS.
11 February
1999 Thursday
Salt Lake City Fairmont Park. Police have been
making visits every hour during the day to the south car lot. At night don't be
shocked to find yourself intersected with some long, grey, late '80's Crown
Victoria while walking across the park. Last Tuesday night (about 8:30) the
monster car drove across the park lawn to stop me, as an ugly young blonde
'community enforcement' officer leapt out of the vehicle, bearing a baton,
inquiring as to my activities. I assured him I was, ahem, waiting for a friend,
and he let me go, assuring me that I was lucky not to be part of the car
cruising scene: "as long as you are not a part of that whole gay thing
because this is gonna stop pretty soon." He seemed pretty frustrated.
13 February
1999 Saturday
Cris Williamson and Tret Fure
in Concert at 7:30 p.m. at Clayton
Intermediate School (1471 S 1800 E) in Salt Lake City. I wish I had the money
to attend.
Weber State's GLSU
(gay/straight alliance) held a Valentine's Dance in "The Lair" at the
Student Union on the Weber State campus. Proceeds went to the Matthew Shepard
Scholarship Fund at WSU.
14 February
1999 Sunday
There was a Valentine's Day
presentation on love, commitment, relationships and union ceremonies from 5 to
7 p.m. at the Weber State University Union building room 338-340. A video of a commitment ceremony was shown
and then a panel lead a discussion about long-term relationships, love,
commitment and more. The panel consisted of Tracy and Marilyn Johnson-Faulkner,
Robert King and his partner Richard, Rev. Bruce Barton and his partner Bruce
Harmon and Kathy Worthington. (Kathy's partner Sara Hamblin was in the
audience.)
15 February
1999 Monday
GAY TEACHERS WENDY WEAVER
LETTER WRITER SAYS DON'T DRAG HATRED INTO WENDY WEAVER CASE Provo Daily Herald,
As the continuing saga of the Wendy Weaver case moves into its latest segment,
I find myself more than a little disturbed by the reactions of some in our
communities. It seems incredible that
those same people who oppose Ms. Weaver's teaching on moral grounds think that
it is acceptable to forget common decency and kindness in expressing their
views. I have been surprised and saddened to hear the hateful, derogatory
comments from people who claim to be upholding a Christian way of life. The
picture of protesters outside the courthouse that recently appeared in The Daily
Herald made my stomach turn. How can
anyone expect right to be on their side when they advocate "death to
homosexuals" and other sentiments that fly in the face of the loving
gospel that Jesus Christ preached? There
are many issues at stake in the Wendy Weaver case and I will be the first to
say that I don't know what the solutions are.
I belong to a religious group that believes homosexuality to be wrong
and I don't condone it. I do accept that
others make choices in their lives, and I don't have to agree with those
choices to treat them as human beings. I have friends who have chosen a
homosexual lifestyle, and the hatred that I see expressed against them in
situations such as this hurts me. We do
not have to embrace or sanction lifestyle choices that we don't agree with, but
we run the risk of repeating a Nazi Germany type society when we introduce
hatred and animosity into an already complex situation. We are in a rather unique position in Utah
Valley, as the moral standards of our community are quite different from those
of the rest of the world. Cases like Wendy Weaver's throw a glaring spotlight
on our challenge to maintain the standards we desire while still allowing
others the freedom to live as they see fit, even though it may clash with our
sense of decency. I don't envy those in
the position of making these decisions.
Whatever the outcomes may be, none of us have "won" if we have
lost our respect, consideration and love for each other in the process. – Wendy
Simmerman, Provo
18 February
1999 Thursday,
Lesbian Utah Rep. Jackie
Biskupski, D-Salt Lake City, former state gay and lesbian Anti-Violence Project
director Laura Milliken Gray, and gay state Democratic leader David Nelson
discussed "Gay and Lesbian Rights" at a Coffee and Politics program
of the University of Utah Hinckley Institute of Politics at 251 Orson Spencer
Hall. GAY RIGHTS ARE CIVIL LIBERTIES, ACCORDING TO SPEAKERS AT THE U The third
wave of the civil rights movement is here. This was the message Utah State
Bar's Alternative Dispute Resolution Chair Laura Milliken Gray and Gay Utah
Democratic Leader David Nelson presented at the Hinckley Institute of Politics
Thursday. Nearly 50 students attended the discussion titled "Gay and
Lesbian Rights." At the turn of the century, women fought for their civil
liberties. African Americans, along with other minorities ,were the second
civil rights wave in the sixties. Is it safe to refer to this as the third
wave? director of the Hinckley Institute Ted Wilson asked. "Yes, that is
exactly the way I see it, and it is a movement that is gaining speed,"
Gray said. Gray is a graduate of the University of Utah, where she earned a
bachelor's and law degrees. It was during her college years that she came out
of the closet. After she received her law degree, she decided she would fight
for gay rights. Gray has spent hours and out of the courtroom fighting for
equal and fair treatment. "The gay community is deprived of rights
everyone else in this community has," Gray said. Gray has fought for equal
rights on insurance, marriage, work opportunity, family adoption, custody and
harassment. "Finding a job after college was difficult. Many law firms
wouldn't hire me because I was a lesbian. Now that I am my own boss it doesn't
matter," Gray said. She is one of a team of lawyers across the nation
working with the East High Gay-Straight Alliance in a lawsuit against the Salt
Lake City School Board. Because of Gay-Straight Alliance, the school board made
a decision to eliminate all non-academic clubs in the school district.
"These kids are very courageous. I didn't know I was gay in high school,
but I think if I did I wouldn't have been open about it. It is a tough time.
Many teenagers contemplate suicide, without the added stress of being a social
outcast," Gray said. "The Matthew Shepard death is an example of how
much hate some people have, " Gray said. Shepard is the University of
Wyoming student who was beaten and left to die because of his sexual
orientation. "Males, and to a lesser extent females, live in fear for things
like holding their partner's hand in public," Gray said. To protect gay
and lesbian people, Gray wants to "use existing laws and add the clause
'sexual orientation' to the end of it," Gray said. This would change laws
such as Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 that prohibit employment
discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex or national origin to
include sexual orientation. Similar laws that prohibit discrimination because
of age or disability would also have the clause 'sexual orientation' added in
them, Gray said. Nelson focused on the statistics of gay voters. The population
of gay people who vote is larger than the Latino, Jewish and Asian American
vote, Nelson said. "This data has helped to change the way candidates try
to attract the gay vote," Nelson said. "Overall, the number of gay
voters is growing. The growth is mostly concentrated in areas like Salt Lake
City. My belief is that these merging demographics will change the way politics
are in Utah," Nelson said. Nelson was a key figure in support of the hate
crime legislation that was defeated at the state capitol earlier this month.
Openly gay Rep. Jackie Biskupski, D-Salt Lake, was scheduled to speak at the
discussion but was unable to because of her work at the Legislature. "We
are always going to have prejudice. Maybe in five to 10 years we can better the
situation. I'm happy to be a small part of it," Gray said. "Speaking
publicly to get the word out that we are normal people: That's the only path to
effectively change the way gay people are seen." (2/18/1999 Jacob
Parkinson Chronicle News Writer)
20 February
1999 Thursday
Gene Siskel died of a Brain
tumor today just 53 years old. He was a film critic and journalist for the
Chicago Tribune. Along with colleague Roger Ebert, he hosted a series of
popular movie review shows on television from 1975 to 1999.
21 February
1999 Friday
In The Limelight University
professor talks frankly about sex Byline: By Debbie Hummel Let's talk about sex. These are four words
that might as well be a four-letter word to some.
University of
Utah professor Patty Reagan has spent her teaching career breaking through the
blushing to deliver the facts about sex, sexuality and sexually transmitted
diseases. Reagan has a doctorate in philosophy and is an associate professor of
Health Promotion and Education. Her academic career has focused on human
sexuality. She is known among students as entertaining and insightful and
comfortable discussing subjects that can make even the most eloquent stumble.
Reagan's professionalism has come after years of study and a few flubs. "I've taught human sexuality for 25
years. For the first 15, it was uncomfortable."
Reagan was on
sabbatical in the mid-'80s at the University of California Berkeley when the
AIDS epidemic was on the minds of many health organizations in the San
Francisco Bay area. Reagan returned to Utah an expert on the latest information
about the virus and was invited often to speak publicly, outside of the
university classroom. She spoke with everyone -- from elementary-school
students to senior citizens.
"It is really hard when what you teach
makes so much sense in a classroom," she said. "All my experience had
been with young adults."
During this
time, Reagan helped found the Salt Lake AIDS Foundation which later merged with
AIDS Project Utah to become the Utah AIDS Foundation. Reagan has fewer outside
commitments now. Her focus is teaching.
Among her
current courses is a Diversity in Health class she feels is particularly
important to future health educators. Cross listed with the Women's Studies
department, the course educates students to better understand diverse
populations when discussing health and sexual issues, clearing up
misinformation and stereotypes of the gay community.
When asked
about the revised release of David Reuben's Everything You Always Wanted to
Know About Sex But Were Afraid to Ask, which claims to have more than 90
percent new information, did little to revise sections on women's sexuality and
homosexuality, Reagan gets a little peeved.
"His [Reuben's] book was inaccurate when it came out. I really am
offended that he didn't go to the experts or to the people," she said.
GAY POLITICS Mayor's Race
Getting Crowded Former Salt Lake City
Councilman Stuart Reid brought himself closer last week to becoming the fourth
candidate for mayor. Reid, a Democrat,
currently is Mayor Deedee Corradini's community and economic development
director. If he runs, he would join fellow Democrats Ross Anderson, a Salt Lake
City civil rights attorney; Dave Jones, the House minority leader; and Jim
Bradley, former Salt Lake County commissioner. Reid is the only west-side
resident in the race and the only Mormon, which should give him some advantage
in the primary. He also seems to have attracted support from Republicans in the
non-partisan race, already winning endorsements from conservative City Council
members Bryce Jolley, Keith Christensen and Carlton Christensen, along with GOP
County Commissioner Brent Overson. Reid
will not announce formally until spring. And he is still formulating his
campaign finance committee, which needs to be registered with the city before
he can raise and spend money. But he has reached an agreement with Caroline
Roemer, who ran the successful re-election campaign of Congressman Merrill
Cook, to be his campaign manager. Roemer is managing public relations for the
Republican caucus at the Utah Legislature.
Prominent Democrat and influential developer Kem Gardner also has agreed
to play an active part in Reid's fundraising activities. The fledgling race
already is showing signs of getting nasty. Earlier this month, GALPAC, the gay
and lesbian political action committee, invited Jones, Anderson and Bradley to
speak to its members. Anderson and Bradley agreed, but Jones declined the
invitation, deferring to his campaign manager, Jennie Wilson, who stated it it
was too early in the campaign. But Wilson showed up at the meeting and took
notes as Bradley and Anderson stated their positions on gay and lesbian issues.
While her note-taking offended some attendees at the meeting, Wilson said it is
typical for candidates or their staffs to take notes on their opponents on debates.
She said any misgivings that Jones would use any gay and lesbian sympathies
against Anderson and Bradley are unwarranted because Jones already has
demonstrated strong positions in favor of gay rights. But the nervousness
caused by the combination of Jones' absence and Wilson's note-taking shows this
already is becoming an uneasy campaign among former political allies.
(SLTRIBUNE)
AIDS ROYAL COURT Close to 200
people gathered at Gastronomy's Salt Lake Hardware building Feb. 21 for the
fourth Food for Hope soiree. The event
raised some $7,000 for AIDS and cancer-related research for the City of Hope
National Medical Center and Beckman Research Institute, Duarte, Calif. Steven Whittaker, chairperson of the Utah
event, told the crowd that Money Magazine recently rated City of Hope
"among the top three most cost-effective health care-related charities in
the country." Also attending were Bridgette Christie and Earl Kane,
reigning empress and emperor of The Royal Court of the Golden Spike Empire.
23 February
1999 Tuesday
GALPAC (Gay and Lesbian
Political Action Committee) is showing a movie, "The Sum of Us", at
Brewvies which will go for the very important municipal races in Salt Lake City
this November.
Dr. Kristen Ries chosen Doctor
of the Year by Utah Medical Association (Chuck Whyte)
28 February
1999 Sunday
Wasatch Affirmation 5pm
Meeting at the home of Paul and Sandy Thomas 484 E 2100 N in Provo Discussion
and Refreshments. To carpool call Rick
Bickmore at 801 860-6497
MARCH
1 March 1999
Monday
GAY POLITICS JACKIE BISKUPSKI
Byline: BY HILARY GROUTAGE THE SALT LAKE TRIBUNE Jackie Biskupski wanted to be
an FBI agent when she graduated from Arizona State University 10 years ago, but
a detour to Utah for a ski vacation changed her plans and made history of sorts
in the state. When she won a
legislative seat in House District 30 last fall, she became Utah's first openly
gay lawmaker. But the 33-year-old Democrat from Minnesota accepts the
distinction with some reluctance.
"To say
that I am the first openly gay elected official is true, but it's not why I
ran," she said. "I'm here to represent everyone." Still, many
say the ever-energetic Salt Lake City resident is in a position to help Utahns become receptive
to gays in politics.
"We're thrilled to have a positive,
openly lesbian person showing an example of how most of us are -- just normal,
happy people working hard and living our lives," said Tracy Vandeventer,
co-leader of Utah's Gay, Lesbian and Straight Education Network.
Her first legislative session nearly
finished, Biskupski happily embraces politics, still awaking every morning
looking forward to the day. No time is spent dwelling on the negative turn of
last fall's election. Her sexual orientation became an issue after Citizens for
Strong Families mailed letters to some 6,000 voters denouncing her
lifestyle.
"The
main message is that our position is against the sin, not the sinner,"
said Steven Barrowes, president of Citizens for Strong Families. Barrowes, an unsuccessful candidate for
Biskupski's seat, has congratulated her on the win and says the two talk
regularly at the Capitol. But Barrowes offers no apology for the mailing.
"This is not an easy subject to be
understood on. If you say it's a sin and you'd like to see someone overcome it,
they say you have sent them hate mail," Barrowes said. "I don't agree
with her, but then we're not in the same political party. We can disagree. I
disagree with a lot of legislators up there, but I can discuss legislation with
her and she knows I'm not vindictive."
Indeed,
Biskupski has no problem with Barrowes or anyone else she has encountered at
the Capitol. Fellow Representative Evan
Olsen, a Republican from Young Ward, looks at Biskupski like he does any other
first-term lawmaker on Capitol Hill.
"They are all representatives, man or woman, black or white, green
or blue," said Olsen, a legislator since 1978. "She was elected by
her constituents and I respect that."
And as far as he can tell, Biskupski is doing the job as she is supposed
to do – representing her constituents.
"You can't judge the first term," he said, adding, "It
takes five or six years to learn the ropes."
Biskupski
knows that and seems to be working to get along with lawmakers and constituents
on both sides of the fence. "No
matter who you are, you have shared values with people. You bring them up and
say these are the things we have in common and you go from there," she
said.
That belief
in commonality has earned her a reputation of being easy to get along with.
Growing up southeast of the Twin Cities in Hastings, Minn., Biskupski was
popular among classmates and known for her tennis game and love of adventure.
"She was
a prankster. We never hurt anyone, but when we went out with her, we always
knew something would happen," said Nancy Lecher, a childhood friend who
now lives in St. Paul, Minn. "She always told us not to worry because she
was in control."
Once, Lecher remembers, she and Biskupski
took a drive in the Minnesota countryside and ended up flattening all four
tires on the car --owned by Biskupski's
mother. "I don't know what we hit,
but I know we were going about 90 miles an hour," Lecher said. Lecher is
part of a closely knit group of school friends who still get together when
Biskupski and her partner of nearly seven years return to Minnesota.
Just after
the 1998 election, the pair again retreated to familiar ground to regroup. "We went to dinner and she started
talking about the negative stuff that happened during the election and I
honestly think she was a little surprised. Being gay is just who she is, it's
like having brown hair or something," Lecher said. "It's not her
whole life."
The rest of
Biskupski's life is full of her work as an insurance investigator, a collector
of antique eye glasses (she has 30 pairs) and countless hours as a volunteer.
She is on the board of the YWCA and describes herself as spiritual. Biskupski
and her partner, who prefers anonymity, attend the Unitarian Church, have two
siamese cats and a Shih Tzu dog. S
he rarely
rejects doing a favor if friends need
help and recently spent the weekend dog-sitting six canines. "If it's not too much for someone to
ask, it's not too much for me to do," she said.
But Biskupski's relaxed demeanor vanishes when
talk turns to certain issues. Child abuse brings her to tears, and when pressed
she acknowledges there have been moments in Utah politics that made her blood
boil. For example, the recent decision
by the state Division of Child and Family Services to ban adoptions of foster
children to gay couples and unmarried heterosexual couples. Did it bother Biskupski? "Like you'll never know," she
said. "These are children who have been born to a mom and dad who can't
raise them. They are in the custody of the state and can't be placed any other
way, and they're saying they would be better off in foster homes? It's truly an
injustice to the child." Domestic
abuse and child abuse? "Just pure
evil," she said.
Among her
successes this year are House Bill 110, a measure that would require financial
disclosure on initiatives that end up at the Legislature or on the ballot, and
passage of the mental health parity bill, which requires health insurers to
cover medical treatment of specific mental illnesses just as they do physical
ailments. She will never run a
frivolous bill, she said, and gets frustrated with lawmakers who do.
"I love
coming here. I really do," she said. "I've worked with the far right
of the GOP and everyone in between. If you are willing to work with anybody in
that room, you can get something done."
2 March 1999 Tuesday
Groups
meeting at the GLCCU- Youth Empowerment Project 7pm upper level at the
Center and Utah Gay Latino Association 7pm lower level at the Center
3 March 1999 Wednesday
Group meeting at the GLCCU-
Family Fellowship 7pm upper level at the Center and
The Alternative Garden Club meets
at 730pm at the Garden Center in Sugar House Park East end by the Rose Garden
4 March 1999 Thursday
Justice Harry Blackmun the
100th Supreme Court Justice (1970-94) who authored the Court's opinion in Roe
v. Wade, died at the age of 90
5 March 1999 Friday
The Utah Gay Rodeo Association
attended the Big Horn Rodeo in Las Vegas. The Royal Court’s Breast Cancer Awareness Week
began with proceeds going to Women’s Breast Cancer Assistance and Research Fund.
All functions throughout the community
bars
6 March 1999 Saturday
The Lambda Hiking Club went Ice Skating - $5 rental fee meet at 1pm
north side of MacFrugals's parking lot 200 S 700 E SLC
KRCL
Radiothon Support Community Radio began. “Phone in your pledge during the
expanded "Concerning Gays and Lesbians" from noon to 1pm. Let's show
KRCL that we care about community radio 359-9191 or 800 359-9191 90.9FM”
The Brass
Rail in Ogden and the Royal Court presented an "All Female Review"
830 pm $5 Hosted by Tonya
7 March 1999 Sunday
The Gay Lesbian Straight
Education Network (GLSEN) met 3-5pm in upper level at the GLCCU.
Wasatch
Affirmation met at 5pm in the MCC at 823 S 600 E. A workshop on love and
personal spirituality was presented by Margo Hope
The Trapp bar
and the Royal Court presented a "Male Stripteaze" 7pm $5 Hosted
by Bridgette and Yvette
I read that film director Stanley Kubrick died at the age
of 70 today. What a legacy did he leave behind, It’s a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad
World, Dr. Strangelove, 2001 A Space Odyssey, A Clockwork Orange and the
Shining. So many more.
8 March 1999 Monday
Joe DiMaggio died today,
baseball Hall of Fame guy and was married to Marilyn Monroe. I heard he always
left roses at her mausoleum. Where have you gone, Joe DiMaggio? A nation turns
its lonely eyes to you Woo, woo, woo What's that you say, Mrs. Robinson? Joltin'
Joe has left and gone away Hey, hey, hey Hey, hey, hey. He was 84 years old.
"Peggy"
Cass, a favorite game show panelist and played Miss Gooch in Auntie Mame died
today. She was 74
the Little
Lavender Book debuted online as kind of a Gay Business directory. www.lavenderbook.com
9 March 1999
Tuesday
the Royal Court held their
business meeting at 7pm in the upper level of the Center
10 March 1999 Wednesday
JACKIE
BISKUPSKI UTAH FIRST OPENLY LESBIAN LEGISLATOR TO SPEAK AT THE CENTER On
Wednesday March 10, Jackie Biskupski, Utah's first openly lesbian legislator,
will be speaking about her experiences being a woman, a lesbian and a Democrat
in her first session of the Legislature.
This free event will begin at 7 p.m. upstairs at "The Center"
- The Gay and Lesbian Community Center of Utah - at 361 N 300 West in Salt
Lake. Men and women of all ages and all
sexual orientations are invited, so invite you friends and relatives .. .
anyone you think would be interested. Yes, you'll have a chance to ask
questions and you can go early or stay late and socialize, too. The Stonewall Coffee shop is downstairs for
your enjoyment, too.
The Rev. Kurt
Howard believes his church congregation made a "bold" and
"courageous" decision selecting him as their new pastor. Perhaps the
first openly gay minister in Utah County, the Rev. Howard says he feels
accepted in an area known for its conservative political and theological views.
"I'm here because the congregation discerned God's future for the
congregation and decided to include me," said the newly appointed pastor
of the Provo Community United Church of Christ, 175 N. University Ave. Clark
Swenson, a member of the church council responsible for the decision to hire a
new reverend, said the Rev. Howard's sexual orientation "was
incidental." "He possesses great leadership abilities, is warm and
genuine, and the bottom line is that he is a good Christian."
Swenson said
some church members may have been hesitant accepting the minister. But upon meeting him, they were won over
because they could accept him "for who he is rather than what he is."
A native of
San Diego, Calif., the Rev. Howard had never been to Utah before his
appointment earlier this year. He said
he is impressed with what he sees here: beautiful mountains and friendly and
diverse people. The reverend feels the United Church of Christ encompasses the
most liberal mainstream congregation in America. Thus, the church attracts
people of all persuasions, those who are open to new ideas.
"Each
person is responsible for discerning their own beliefs," he said. He
doesn't consider his congregation liberal or conservative, but
"searching." Here, he said "diversity is not tolerated but
celebrated."
"Coming
out to himself," as the Rev. Howard describes confronting his sexual
orientation, was for him "a crisis and a painful decision." He had never considered himself gay. He married, had children and was content with
"the American dream." It wasn't until after a divorce four years ago
he began to experience different feelings.
His biggest concern was how to tell his family members, but even that
had a positive outcome. They were
supportive and loving, he said.
During his 12
years in the U.S. Navy, the reverend served as a chaplain, a capacity he
enjoyed. Still, he wasn't exactly sure
what God wanted him to do with his life.
He said he just knew he wanted to serve God in some way. After leaving
the Navy, he enrolled as a theology student at Claremont School of Divinity in
Claremont, Calif., and graduated three years later with a master's in
theology.
He began
searching for an area where he could be of greatest worth. He served as an
assistant pastor in California and Pennsylvania but wanted a congregation of
his own. In his interview for the Provo church position, he talked with the
five-member council about his lifestyle, about his desire to serve and what he
would hope to accomplish while here. The
interview, he said, was positive, and he was anxious to get to work. After the council chose him, the church
congregation gave its final approval.
As the new
pastor, he wants everyone to know they will be accepted "just the way they
are."
Toni
Billings, another member of the search committee, said when they considered
hiring the Rev. Howard, they did some in-depth thinking, studying, and with
much prayer, received the confirmation that he was the one to serve here. "We did have a lot to consider,"
she said, adding that the Rev. Howard has a "high degree of integrity and
was completely up front with the issues. He's a good person, so we had to side
with that."
While the
Rev. Howard said he has heard rumors that some people are upset about the
decision to hire him, no one has said anything to him personally. "Those
who are believing would be delighted" to have a gay pastor, said Doug
Wortham, executive director of the Gay and Lesbian Community of Utah. Wortham
said that while many communities nationwide have gay pastors, he is not aware
that there have been any in Utah County.
In past
pastoral callings, the Rev. Howard has focused mainly on "the church side
of the call" but feels there is so much more that needs to be done. He doesn't want just a "Sunday
church" but a community center where people are involved with others each
day of the week in various activities.
An HIV-AIDS
group meets each Thursday with church members to discuss problems and give
encouragement to each other. The Rev.
Howard wants this meeting to be helpful for those with the virus, as well as
families and friends. He plans to invite
guest speakers to provide the latest information. Children and youths are
taught in special classes and involved inservice projects.
In 1986, the
Community Church began the Food and Care Coalition, which continues to serve
needy people. This is a good project,
the Rev. Howard said, and as an added goal, he would like his congregation to
"pay more attention to the homeless in our midst and look for
opportunities to love them."
11 March 1999
Thursday
The weekly meeting of "Coloring
Outside the Lines", the GLBT student group at the South Campus of the Salt
Lake Community College, will feature Kathy Worthington of "Kathy's
List". Topics: The Millennium March on Washington (scheduled for April 30,
2000) and fighting homophobia in your daily life. Some go for coffee afterwards
at The Center. It's free and men and women of all ages invited. No need to be affiliated in any way with the
Community College.
Erick Myers Gay Psychic -
Intuitive reading on relationships, careers, finance and matters of the heart
7pm Coffee Shop at the Center - no charge
Radio City and the Royal Court
present "Un-Drage" 9pm $5 Hosted by Wilma and Bredgette
12 March 1999 Friday
Axis and the Royal Court
present "Pink Party" 8pm $5 Hosted by Empress Bridgette Bricks and
the Royal Court present "Un-Drage" 1130pm $5 Hosted by Sheneka
There was an AIDS death in the
obituaries today. Christopher Shawn Mason, AKA Byron Authur Miller II, 35,
passed away March 8, 1999. Chris was a kind, gentle spirit who will be greatly
missed and lovingly remembered. Thanks go to caretakers Dr. Kristin Ries and
Mr. Charles A. Daniels. A Memorial will be held Saturday, March 13, 1999 from
7-8 p.m. at Arts of Utah, 2226 So. 700 East, Salt Lake City, Utah. In lieu of
flowers, please donate to Utah Aids
Foundation. 03/12/1999 Page: C6
13 March 1999 Saturday
Lesbian comic Nancy Norton
will be performing at the Center Presented by Lavendar Productions of Evanston
Two shows at 7pm and 9pm, reception at 8pm
$20 per ticket to benefit Utah gay youth who are raising funds to attend
Boston's Gay Youth Pride celebration
call 539-8800 to find out how to get tickets from the Gay Straight alliances
The Sun and the Royal Court
present "Empress Show" 8pm $5 Hosted by the College of Empresses
14 March 1999 Sunday
The Wasatch Mountain Bears held
their Sunday Brunch 11am at The Olympian 2181 S 700 E
Gay and
Lesbian Political Action Committee (GALPAC) met at 1-3pm upper level of
the Center
Wasatch
Affirmation met at 5pm in Ogden at the Viking Villa Club House 433 E 980 N
enter from 450 E off 900 N
The Royal
Court presents "Name that Drag" 830pm at the Sun Club $5
donation Boys impersonate the Queens
15 March 1999 Monday
The Women's Book Club and the Inklings
Bookstore present a discussion of Rita
Will (Rita Mae Brown Autobiography) 7pm
upper level at the Center
16 March 1999 Tuesday
The Youth Empowerment Project met
at 7pm upper level at the Center. The Gay Men's Singles Mixer met a 7pm Coffee
Shop at the Center Conversation,
Videos and "WILL & GRACE" bring treats
17 March 1999 Wednesday
PFLAG Parents and Friends of
Lesbians and Gays (P-Flag) 7pm upstairs at the Center
WEAVER
LAWSUIT WHITTLED DOWN Deseret News, By Jeffrey P. Haney, PROVO – A 4th District
Court lawsuit filed by a citizens group that wants gay teacher Wendy Weaver
dismissed from her post at a Utah County high school was whittled down
considerably in a ruling issued late Tuesday. Although the majority of
complaints by the Citizens for Nebo School District for Moral and Legal Values
were dismissed, Judge Ray Harding Jr. left intact claims that Weaver violated
religious and personal rights of some students while working at Spanish Fork
High School. Harding felt the group provided sufficient evidence to proceed to
trial with two claims. The plaintiffs
say that Weaver criticized the LDS Church in class and that her access to the
girls locker room violated one student's religious rights because of her
beliefs on homosexuality. Dismissed complaints in the 48-page ruling include
allegations that Weaver endorsed specific religious viewpoints, violated rights
given to parents by the Utah Constitution, overstepped a state law that
prohibits the use of psychological tests in schools without written consent
from parents or guardians and broke rules governing the Psychological Licensing
Act. Harding also dismissed the claim that Weaver's teaching certificate should
be taken away because her marital-like relationship with a woman may violate
the state's sodomy laws. "The important thing is that Wendy was vindicated
in almost every respect," said Stephen Clark, an attorney for the Utah
ACLU who is working in Weaver's defense in tandem with Salt Lake attorney
Richard Van Wagoner. However, Clark said the legal team will request a
clarification on the two counts Harding allowed to remain in the suit,
particularly the assertion that Weaver's presence in a locker room may violate
a student's rights. Jeana Barney, a former student at Spanish Fork High, was
offended by Weaver's presence in the locker room. Barney said she had undressed in Weaver's
presence but would not have had she known Weaver was a lesbian. Shesaid the state should protect students
like her from individuals whose beliefs or lifestyles differ from theirs.
"She doesn't prowl around in the locker room," Clark said. "She didn't do anything. The claim is that because Wendy simply had
access, her rights were infringed." Matt Hilton, legal counsel for the
Nebo group, said he was pleased that some of the claims were allowed to go
forward but objected to Harding's removal of Attorney General Jan Graham from
the suit as a defendant. Craig Jackson, director of Utah's Division of
Occupational and Professional Licensing, also was dismissed as a
defendant. Four plaintiffs were also
dismissed because they could not show they had been directly harmed by Weaver's
continued employment at the district. Tuesday's decision is the latest in a
string of legal decisions that have favored Weaver, who told Nebo School
District administrators in 1997about her sexual orientation. In November, U.S.
District Judge Bruce Jenkins ruled for Weaver in a federal civil-rights suit
that claimed she was illegally refused a job as a volleyball coach and was told
she could not discuss her sexual orientation with students or staff at the
school. Nebo officials, ordered by
Jenkins to remove letters from Weaver's personnel file and offer her a job as
volleyball coach, opted not to appeal the decision. Weaver continues to teach at Spanish Fork
High School, instructing psychology and co-ed volleyball courses. She has decided to decline the offer to coach
the school's team next year.
JUDGE ELIMINATES MOST COUNTS
IN CIVIL LAWSUIT AGAINST SPANISH FORKTEACHER WENDY WEAVER Salt Lake Tribune, BY
HILARY GROUTAGE, THE SALT LAKE TRIBUNE
A lawsuit filed by a group of Utah County residents seeking to oust
lesbian teacher Wendy Weaver was pared significantly Tuesday by 4th District
Judge Ray Harding Jr., but he left intact claims that Weaver violated students'
religious and personal liberties. Harding said the suit could proceed on claims
that Weaver, a Spanish Fork High School psychology teacher, made derogatory
statements about the LDS Church and that her presence in a girls locker room
offended one student's religious beliefs about homosexuality. Nevertheless,
said Weaver's attorney, Rick Van Wagoner, "Judge Harding's decision
vindicates Wendy Weaver on almost every score." But plaintiffs' attorney
Matt Hilton said the ruling raised serious questions about whether parents can
turn to the courts for relief when issues such as those involving Weaver's
fitness to teach arise. Two of nine counts in the complaint, filed by Citizens
for Moral and Legal Values in Nebo School District, were left in place in the
48-pageruling. Earlier, Hilton agreed to
withdraw a claim that Weaver had inappropriate contact with female students.
The lawsuit is the second in as many years for Weaver, who publicly
acknowledged in 1997 that she is a lesbian. That year, she filed a federal
civil-rights suit against the Nebo School District after officials told her she
could not coach the girl's volleyball team or discuss her sexual orientation
with students. Late last year, U.S.
District Judge Bruce Jenkins ruled in Weaver's favor. In his Tuesday ruling,
Harding dismissed claims that: • Weaver violated the Utah Family Educational
Rights and Privacy Act, which prohibits administration of psychological tests
without written consent of student's parents or guardian. • Weaver violated the
Psychologist Licensing Act. • Weaver violated parental rights protected by the
Utah Constitution. • She violated the Constitutional Freedoms in the Schools
Act, which states that school officials and employees may not use their
positions to endorse, promote or disparage a particular religious viewpoint. •
Weaver's lesbianism violated Utah's teacher certification requirements because
she may be in violation of the state's sodomy law by living with her
partner. Three of the counts involved
that issue. The two remaining counts deal with the Utah Constitution's
provisions on religious liberties, privacy rights and equal protection under
the law. Count V claims that Joshua Lee, a student in Weaver's
advanced-placement psychology class, said his rights were violated when Weaver
made disparaging remarks about the Mormon Church during class. Weaver said Tuesday she does not recall what
those remarks were. Count VII claims Jeana Barney, a former student at Spanish
Fork High, was offended by Weaver's presence in the women's locker room. Barney said she had undressed in Weaver's
presence before Weaver came out as a lesbian.
Barney claimed that had she known Weaver was a lesbian, she would not
have changed in her presence. She also
claimed Weaver violated her right to privacy, and that the state should protect
students like her from individuals whose beliefs or lifestyles differ from
theirs. Weaver said Barney never was
her student and she does not recall ever seeing her in the locker room.
"In 19 years of teaching, I've never had a girl even use the shower,
"Weaver said. "Girls would much rather shower at home." Attorney
Van Wagoner said he is preparing a request for clarification on the remaining
two counts and is particularly troubled about Barney's complaint. "Are we going to have to create
separate facilities for everybody?
The people who are offended go
here and the ones who are not offended go there? How can someone's status, be
it black, gay or lesbian, violate someone's civil rights?" Hilton, the plaintiffs' attorney, took
particular issue with Hardings' ruling that the Utah state Board of Education
and the state Division of Professional Licensing were the proper forum for
questions about whether Weaver improperly administered a psychology test to
students. He also objected to Harding's
decision to remove Utah Atty. Gen. Jan Graham as a plaintiff. "This raises
a significant question about disenfranchising parents" from the ability to
turn to the courts for relief, Hilton said. Weaver has said she had proper
parental permission to administer the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality
Inventory, MMPI, and that her former husband, Gary, a licensed psychologist who
works for the Nebo School District, interpreted the results. Meantime, Weaver remains a popular
advanced-placement psychology teacher at Spanish Fork High School. She also teaches a coed volleyball class, but
has decided against coaching the girl's volleyball team next year, even though
the federal court decision in her favor forced the school to offer her the job.
(17 March 1999 Wednesday 03/17/1999 Page: A1 )
18 March 1999 Thursday
GAY TEACHERS UTAH ANTI-GAY
GROUP IN UTAH COUNTY LIKELY TO APPEAL RULING IN LAWSUIT AGAINST WENDY WEAVER
Deseret News, By Jeffrey P. Haney, Deseret News staff writer PROVO — Matt
Hilton sighs when asked how many hours he has dedicated to a lawsuit filed by a
group of Utah County conservatives in an attempt to oust gay teacher Wendy
Weaver from her job. "Too many," Hilton says, sounding notably
disappointed with a ruling issued Tuesday by 4th District Judge Ray Harding Jr.
dismissing all but two misconduct claims against Weaver, a psychology
teacher. Claims that Weaver violated
religious and personal rights of some students while working at Spanish Fork
High School were left intact. An appeal of the ruling is likely, he said. And if an amended complaint is filed, the
Nebo School District may be added as a defendant with Weaver and the Utah State
Board of Education. "I'd rather
not," he said. "We've been
pretty resistant to the option, but it is one we will look at." By adding
Nebo to the defendant list, Hilton believes his arguments may be more
applicable. Although the judge dismissed
four plaintiffs Tuesday because they weren't directly affected by Weaver's
employment, Hilton said they may be able to remain by claiming an interest in
how taxes are spent. His clients, the Citizens of the Nebo School District for
Moral and Legal Values, also say they should have rights to seek recourse from
the courts if school boards refuse to take action against a teacher whose personal
or professional conduct is called into question by parents. Harding, though,
refused to issue a judgment against Weaver based on Hilton's claims that Weaver
is unfit as a teacher and practiced psychology without a license in her
classes. "The statutory claims brought by the plaintiffs request this
court render a decision on issues that have been statutorily delegated
elsewhere," Harding wrote. Utah's
laws, he said, grant the state board of education "exclusive
authority" over matters dealing with certified teachers. Harding said he is bound only to "compel
the requisite administrative bodies to comply with mandatory disciplinary
procedures" in issues regarding teacher certification. "If that is
his perspective, then parents have nowhere to go," Hilton said. "That's my opinion." Stephen Clark,
an attorney for the Utah ACLU, said the irony of Hilton's suit is that
conservative groups historically have implored the court not to meddle in
decisions by school boards, which are made up of community members who are
familiar with local standards. Clark and Hilton said they will draft requests
for clarification on claims that were left untouched in the suit. Both want the judge to further explain his
reasoning for not dismissing the claim by a student that her religious rights
were violated by Weaver's access to the locker room. The judge ruled that
because student Jeana Barney's beliefs include modesty and chastity and because
Weaver had publicly revealed her same-sex attraction, Barney's rights may have
been infringed upon because her
participation in school activities required her to use the locker room.
"Wendy didn't do anything wrong," Clark said, noting that there was
no other way for Weaver to enter her office without first walking through the
locker room. "What would that mean
for the school? For the principal?
That's quite an unclear part of the ruling." "The way he handled the locker room
questions caused more problems than it solved," Hilton agreed. The other
remaining claim, that Weaver demeaned the LDS Church, will also be debated at a
trial. "Wendy is confident that
once the facts come out, she will be vindicated," Clark said. "She has made an effort not to offend
anyone for their religious beliefs."
Harding's ruling brings Weaver's legal battles closer to an end. Four months ago, U.S. District Judge Bruce
Jenkins issued a ruling in favor of Weaver's claims that her rights of privacy
and due process were violated by Nebo School District officials when they took
away her job as volleyball coach and asked her not to discuss her same-sex
partnership with students.
19 March 1999 Friday
Today is Career Ladder Day as
it’s the end of the third term so no school for the kids. I had most of their
grades already done so I mainly lessoned planned and changed bulletin boards.
Paul Kenny is a human Academy
Award on Thursday at Salt Lake City's Trolley Square, promoting the Utah AIDS
Foundation's Oscar Night Gala.
20 March 1999 Saturday
Today is the first day of
spring and my globe willows are already leafing out.
The Western Trans-sexuals
Support Network (WSTN) 10am-noon upstairs at the Center and Engendered Species held
a Drop In Open House 7-10pm Coffee Shop at the Center
The Wasatch
Mountain Bears St Patty Party at Todd and Ron's 951 E Charlton Circle. I used
to go to them and sit in their hot tub. They were fun but I just don’t feel
like it anymore.
ANTI GAY RELIGION GAY
PENTACOSTALS CHALLENGE VIEWS ON HOMOSEXUALITY Gay Pentecostals? To a movement
whose roots are deep in the late 19th century's fundamentalist Christian
holiness tradition, the term is certainly a theological oxymoron. Mainline
Pentecostals -- unique for an exuberant style of worship that includes speaking
in tongues -- quote scripture from both the Old and New Testaments to declare
homosexuality sin. "We take what
the Bible stands for," said the Rev. Bob Palmer, pastor of Salt Lake City's
Church of God of Prophecy (COGOP). "We don't hate gays, but the Bible does
condemn that lifestyle." In a stand shared with other Pentecostals and
fundamentalists, the 400,000-member COGOP believes the Old Testament account of
the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah is ample evidence of God's condemnation
of same-sex relations. In the King James
version's Genesis 19 account, a mob of men demand Lot release to them two
visiting male angels "that we may know them." Lot's offer instead of
his two virgin daughters is angrily rejected, the mob rushes the door of Lot's
home and are blinded by the angels.
Later, after Lot and his family escape, Sodom and Gomorrah are destroyed
by a rain of fire and brimstone.
However, the Universal Fellowship of Metropolitan Community Churches – a
denomination founded by in 1968 by Troy Perry, a gay minister defrocked by
COGOP -- has a different take. The Rev. Jim Morgan, pastor of the MCC churches
in Salt Lake City and Ogden, refers to the Sodom and Gomorrah story and other key
scriptures as "the clobber passages." "It is my belief and the belief of my
denomination that when they are correctly translated they do not speak to
lesbian, gay persons," he said. MCC maintains that the sin of Sodom was in
hospitality, not homosexuality. Some theologians agree, among them the Rev. L.
Robert Arthur of Samaritan Theological Institute in Los Angeles.
"Theologians have been guilty for centuries of playing on this unfortunate
misunderstanding to condemn those who found their sexual orientation to be
homosexual," Arthur wrote in his booklet Homosexuality and the
Conservative Christian. Similar claims of misinterpretation also are used to
address such condemnations in other scriptures. One, Leviticus 18:22, declares:
"Thou shalt not lie with mankind, as with womankind: it is
abomination." The punishment? Death. In the New Testament, Paul's epistle
to the Romans condemns men "leaving the natural use of the woman."
Later, in I Corinthians, the apostle includes "effeminate [and] abusers of
themselves with mankind" with adulterers, drunkards, thieves and
extortioners on a list of the hell bound. In his pamphlet Homosexuality: not a
sin, not a sickness, the MCC's Rev. Elder Donald Eastman argues that Paul
referred to same-sex activity resulting from idolatrous activity, not
"loving, responsible lesbian and gay relationships seen today." Such
reasoning is convoluted error, conservative theologians maintain. The Rev.
Timothy Crater of the National Association of Evangelicals prefers "a
literal, normal, face-value interpretation of the Bible. "Some people
attempt to keep some form of Christianity and hold on to homosexuality,
too," he told Knight Ridder. "It leads to strange interpretations of
the Bible." Palmer, meantime, finds at least one point where he agrees
with Morgan and the MCC: God loves gays and lesbians, too. "We want to reach gays and touch gays
spiritually; we're not against them personally," Palmer said. "If we
could, we'd reach every one of them with the saving knowledge that Christ offers."
METROPOLTAN COMMUNITY CHURCH:
BY BOB MIMS THE SALT LAKE TRIBUNE
OGDEN -- The speakers are cranked up at Glory to God Metropolitan
Community Church, and you can feel the drums of the revival band Chadash
beating in your chest. "God is in
the house, there ain't no doubt." the congregation of 60 sings,
punctuating the lyrics with "amens" and "hallelujahs" that
float above a forest of swaying hands. Finally, the music stops. A truce has
been declared with the blaring whistles of occasional freight trains rolling
through west Ogden just a few blocks away. An electric silence descends as
worshippers catch their breath. The Rev.
Yolande Yaeger takes the pulpit. It's time, she says, to get right with
God. "We don't have to be perfect
little Christians," Yaeger declares. "This place would be empty if
that was so -- and so would heaven.
"But you need to be born again by the spirit of God. Take that step
of faith," she concludes, turning her head toward the ceiling. "Lord,
meet us at the altar. Our faith will rise to meet you, Lord." It could be any small Pentecostal church in
the United States, with one exception both subtle and glaring: In a worldwide
movement known for its rock-ribbed conservatism as much as its emotional
worship, the overwhelming majority of those at Metropolitan Community this
night are gays and lesbians. Perhaps a half-dozen worshippers answer Yaeger's
altar call, drifting toward the platform for prayer. A few folding-chair rows
behind them, two young men cling to each other, one caressing the small of his
companion's back. As the music becomes more subdued, two women embrace, dancing
slowly in place. Up front, Yaeger prays
for a college-aged youth to find his "soul mate." She lays hands on
him, he quivers at if taking a high-voltage shock and collapses in ecstasy,
"slain by the spirit." A few
feet away, a trio of women pray for a middle-aged man. Tears flow, and after a
few moments his hands stretch toward the ceiling and he begins to sputter,
speaking in tongues. The Rev. Jim Morgan, pastor of the church, and his
partner, Joseph Wegener, smile with satisfaction over the flock's
response. They have been together since
they met in Alaska 20 years ago. Wegener, 48, works as an alcohol and drug
abuse counselor; Morgan, 52, is in full-time ministry, shuffling between his
Ogden congregation and one at Sacred Light of Christ MCC in Salt Lake City.
Morgan's clerical collar, accessorized with a large brass cross dangling over
his green satin robe, hints at his Roman Catholic upbringing and early interest
in the priesthood. "It was when I
was in seminary I discovered I was gay," he said. "I left the
seminary. At the time, I thought the last thing the church needed was a gay
priest. "I spent the next 12 to 13
years just sort of wandering in a spiritual vacuum. Then Troy Perry founded the
Metropolitan Community Church (in 1968, after being defrocked by his
Pentecostal denomination for being gay)."
Morgan soon became a minister in the denomination that now serves more
than 40,000 members in 15 nations.
Earlier in the service, Stacey and Judy, a lesbian couple, slipped into
the night for a cigarette. Going on
their eighth year together, they talked about how their long search for an
"accepting, affirming" religious environment had finally ended at
MCC. "You're not condemned here.
You're not told you're going to hell. You're told that you're loved -- there's
a big difference," Stacey said.
"In [other] Pentecostal churches they get up there and tell you
homosexuality is wrong," she added. "I have to be me and be happy. If
that means going to hell, then so be it."
Judy said she came to MCC knowing she "was missing that religious
part of my life. "These people here
just make you feel like you're loved. They want you to be happy." Inside, the all-lesbian Chadash rocks the
aging former Catholic chapel where Morgan founded Glory to God MCC in 1996.
During a more contemplative break, Yaeger's partner, the diminutive Rev. Lee
Thompson, does an expressive liturgical dance as the band sings. And Yaeger
preaches her gospel of acceptance.
"We're all on a lifelong journey," she says. "We need
something to sustain us." Another
train clatters down the tracks, its whistle fading toward an unknown
destination.
THREE UTAH MCC CHURCHES TO
PARTICIPATE IN 'EQUALITY BEGINS AT HOME' Deseret News, Utah churches to join
gay rally By Carrie A. Moore, Deseret News religion editor Members of three
Utah congregations affiliated with the Universal Fellowship of Metropolitan
Community Churches will participate in a nationwide mobilization of gay and
lesbian activists scheduled March 21-27. Called "Equality Begins At
Home," the series of marches, protests and rallies is being dubbed
"one of the largest grassroots organizing campaigns in the history of the
(national) Gay and Lesbian Task Force movement," with" actions in all
50 states" to focus attention on legislative battles over gay rights. In Utah, a rally has been scheduled for
Saturday, March 27, at noon on the steps of the state Capitol to push for passage
of a non-discrimination bill. The Rev. Jim Morgan, pastor of Glory to God
Metropolitan Community Church in Ogden, said members of his church – along with
Metropolitan Community Church congregations in Logan and Salt Lake City – will
support the national event. "We
have a three-pronged approach to the gospel, and the third prong is social
justice. We believe the church must also
be involved in that." Even so, the Rev. Morgan says he is not aware of any
efforts by church members to actually lobby legislators in Utah. "That's a little too organized for what
we're doing here. Most of the people
here in Ogden exercise their right to change legislation by voting." The
Rev. Morgan said services at Metropolitan Community Churches – all of which
affirm gay, lesbian and transgendered members – follow "very mainstream
Protestant Christianity. They include charismatic singing, evangelical
preaching and a communion service" that is more liturgical than most. Formed in 1968 "as a healing response to
the condemnation lesbians and gay men experience in most Christian
denominations," members of MCC churches "celebrate the fullness of
the gospel – the Good News of God's love through Jesus Christ to every
person," according to information on the parent organization's Web site.
Many members of the Rev. Morgan's congregations (he's also serving as pastor of
Salt Lake's Sacred Light of Christ Metropolitan Community Church) were
"emotionally and spiritually bleeding" when they found the church, he
said. Homosexuality is "a topic
most people would rather not deal with.
It conjures up their views of AIDS and death and 'people getting their
just deserts' for what they've done."
Indeed, how to handle same-sex marriage and homosexual clergy are issues
that continue to divide many mainstream Protestant denominations. Several have used the Bible as the basis for
legislated church policy on the issues, only to have those policies continually
challenged. Individual churches withdraw
from some denominations in protest. Talk
of schism and separation abounds. Yet the Ogden congregation has found
"some very good friends in the Methodist Church and the United Church of
Christ. There are also some
Episcopalians – in most cases it's pockets rather than whole groups of
people," the Rev. Morgan said. Such
dialogue with other churches "has been slow (coming), but I have a lot of
hope for it. "As people see
that we don't have three heads and four arms – we're not the monsters people
have painted us to be. With interfaith
dialogue, maybe it becomes nothing more than we agree to disagree. But it's very difficult to hate someone with
a face – and very easy to hate a group you don't know."
21 March 1999 Sunday
Wasatch Affirmation met at 5pm at MCC to watch a video and had a discussion
"All God's Children"
The Utah AIDS Foundation’s Gala
Oscar Night Party fundraiser was held at the Doubletree Hotel SLC. Joe Redburn
at the The Trapp held am Academy Awards Night Celebration 7pm. The Utah Gay
Latino Association held a dance at Brick's at 9pm
23 March 1999 Tuesday
NEBO SCHOOL DISTRICT ORDERED
TO PAY COSTS IN WEAVER LAWSUITTHE DESERET NEWS
Nebo School District's losing bid to silence teacher Wendy Weaver will
cost the district $61,910.U.S. District Senior Judge Bruce S. Jenkins has
ordered the district to pay that amount to cover Weaver's attorney fees and
legal expenses in her year-long legal battle. Weaver, a Spanish Fork High
School teacher since 1982, sued the district in 1997 after school officials
ordered her not to discuss her "homosexual orientation and lifestyle."
Jenkins ruled in November that the sweeping ban along with the school's
decision not to renew Weaver's volleyball coaching assignment violated her
constitutional rights. With the ruling, Weaver won damages totaling $1,500.As
the prevailing party in the lawsuit, Weaver last week was further awarded
attorney fees and legal expenses. She was represented by attorneys David
Watkiss, Jennifer Middleton and Stephen Clark.
GALPAC GAY CIVIL RIGHTS RALLY
UTAH - TINY RALLY AT THE STATE CAPITOL BEGINS WEEK OF ANTI-GAY COUNTER-
DEMONSTRATIONS BY RIGHT WING CONSERVATIVES by Kathy Worthington, Salt Lake City
A handful of right wing conservatives rallied at the Utah State Capitol on
Tuesday March 23 in the first of a week of rallies meant to counteract the gay
rights rallies being held across the country this week. The group also reportedly plans to be at the
Capitol on Saturday, when a Utah rally is planned as part of nationwide "Equality
Begins At Home" events, according to as spokesperson for the Gay and
Lesbian Political Action Committee (GALPAC), one of the groups organizing the
Saturday rally. Just how many conservatives will actually come out for the
anti-gay counter-demonstration is not known, of course, as such efforts have
not drawn large groups in the past, at least not in Utah. That this writer can remember, the only time
in the past that a fairly large number of people has turned out on the
"anti-gay" side was at a Salt Lake City school board meeting to
discuss the gay clubs issue, and, even at that 1996 meeting, those who favored
outlawing gay clubs were outnumbered by those in favor of the clubs. One
positive side of the conservative's decision to counter-demonstrate is that it
means the mainstream media will be more likely to cover the event and discuss
the issues. Coverage of such events in the mainstream media is one way to get
people thinking about and discussing the issues. Such coverage is also often a catalyst for
getting closeted gay people to come out and to get involved. Some gay or
gay-friendly people, however, get frightened by the presence of anti-gay
demonstrators and/or the media and that makes them stay away from events like
Saturday's rally. It will be interesting
to see how many folks each side is able to get to the rally.
24 March 1999 Wednesday
I went to the Gay and Lesbian
Community Center tonight as part of my Utah Stonewall Historical Society
Lecture. Doug Wortham asked me a while
back if I would consider doing a talk about Community Building in the 1980's.
We met upstairs and only about 5 people showed up who I think just wandered up
from the coffee shop downstairs. I am not sure if it’s worth it to continue in
person meetings.
BOTH SIDES ASK FOR DISMISSAL
OF LAST TWO COUNTS IN CIVIL LAWSUIT AGAINST SPANISH FORK TEACHER WENDY WEAVER
Conservative Group that filed the suit wants to appeal it to higher court
Wednesday, March 24, 1999 SALT LAKE TRIBUNEBY HILARY GROUTAGETHE SALT LAKE
TRIBUNE Attorneys on both sides have
asked that the two remaining counts of a law suit against Spanish Fork High
School teacher Wendy Weaver be dismissed to clear the way for an appeal of the
case. The stipulation and motion was
filed in 4th District Court in Provo on Tuesday, said attorney Matthew Hilton,
who represents the citizens group working to oust Weaver, a psychology teacher,
former volleyball coach and lesbian. "This clears the way for us to have a
clean appeal" to the Utah Supreme Court, said Hilton, who wants to pursue
the dismissed claims involving parents' rights to turn to the courts if local
and state school boards do not, or cannot, address their concerns. Last week, 4th District Judge Ray Harding
Jr. dismissed all but two of the nine counts contained in a 1997 lawsuit filed
against Weaver, who divulged her sexual orientation earlier that year. The
remaining counts involve former Spanish Fork High School students who said they
were harmed by Weaver's remarks in class and her presence in the girls' locker
room. In Count 5, former student Joshua Lee said Weaver had offended him with
remarks about the Mormon tradition of farewell testimonials for departing
missionaries; he claimed Weaver said the meetings serve a social function rather
than a spiritual one. Lee also objected to Weaver's suggestion that her
then-husband, Gary Weaver, should read books besides the Book of Mormon to
their children. Wendy Weaver and Gary Weaver were later divorced. Count 7 is based on a statement by
plaintiff Jeana Barney, who claimed she had undressed in the girls locker room,
then felt uncomfortable about it after she learned that Weaver was a lesbian.
Weaver has said Barney never was her student, and that she has no recollection
of being in the locker room at the same time she was. In the stipulation and
motion filed Tuesday, and agreed to by attorneys on both sides, Count 5 would
be dismissed without prejudice, meaning it could be refiled later. Count 7
would be dismissed with prejudice, meaning it would not be revisited. A longer,
more detailed order asking Harding to dismiss the counts will be filed later
this week, Hilton said. The seven dismissed claims are the ones Hilton most
fervently wants to argue in court. Parents, Hilton said, should have a right to
turn to the courts if they believe school boards have not properly handled
their complaints about their children's schooling. "Parental consent, practicing
psychology without a license. We think we have a right to sue on that,"
Hilton said. Hilton and the 13 plaintiffs claimed in the original lawsuit that
Weaver was unfit to be a teacher because she is a lesbian and that she violated
the Utah Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, the Psychology Licensing
Act, the Constitutional Freedoms in Schools Act and Utah's teacher
certification requirements. The lawsuit claimed Weaver had administered
psychological tests to students while teaching psychology courses, had made
inappropriate comments about the Mormon church in the course of her lectures and
had inappropriate contact with female students. The 4th District lawsuit is the
second in as many years that Weaver has been involved in. The first she filed
herself in U.S. District Court against the Nebo School District after officials
told her she could not coach the girl's volleyball team or discuss her sexual
orientation with students. Late last year, Judge Bruce Jenkins ruled in
Weaver's favor and the school district was forced to offer Weaver her coaching
job again. She declined. Last Friday, Jenkins ordered the Nebo School District
to pay Weaver's legal fees in the case. The fees total $61,910.46. Rick Van
Wagoner, a cooperating attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union who is
representing Weaver in the 4th District Court case, said Weaver will win the
latest case on appeal. "We're going
to claim victory on this," he said.
CIVIL LAWSUIT AGAINST WENDY
WEAVER IS FAR FROM OVER DESERET NEWS, March 24, 1999 Weaver lawsuit is set for
dismissal — but legal battle is far from over By Jeffrey P. Haney, Deseret News
staff writer PROVO — A 4th District Court lawsuit seeking to oust Wendy Weaver
from her teaching job could be soon dismissed — but the legal battle is far
from over. A motion to dismiss two
remaining counts against the gay Spanish Fork educator was prepared to clear
the way for an appeal to the Utah Supreme Court, said the legal team for the
Citizens of the Nebo School District for Moral and Legal Values. Matt Hilton,
attorney for the citizens group, was disappointed at last week's ruling by
Judge Ray Harding Jr., who only allowed two of nine claims in a 1997 suit
against Weaver to remain. He said the ruling stymies the rights of parents to
seek address in courts if school boards do not address their concerns.
Attorneys on both sides had asked for summary judgment on the counts, which
included a claim that Weaver was practicing psychology without a license in her
classroom. Left intact were two claims that Weaver violated religious and
personal rights of some students.
"We feel there were substantial problems with the ruling,"
said a spokesman for Hilton's office. "The purpose (for the motion to
dismiss) is so we can take it up on appeal." The counts that will be
dismissed both involve students who say they were harmed by Weaver's alleged
derogatory statements about Utah's dominant religion and her access to the
women's locker room. Among the counts remaining, a former Spanish Fork student,
who never was Weaver's student, feels her rights were violated by having to
change clothes in the locker room near the former coach's office. This claim
will be dismissed with prejudice.
Another student said he was offended when Weaver reportedly told classes
that an LDS tradition of holding farewell meetings for missionaries had
"no purpose." Both sides agreed to dismiss this claim without
prejudice. The 13 plaintiffs claimed in the initial 4th District suit that
Weaver, as a gay woman, was morally unfit to be a teacher. They also said she
stepped over legal lines drawn by the Utah Family Educational Rights and
Privacy Act, the Psychology Licensing Act, the Constitutional Freedoms in Schools
Act and the Utah's teacher certification requirements. Harding dismissed those claims last week, but
spurred the most recent legal action. In November, Weaver won a U.S. District
Court suit against the Nebo School District for violating her rights of privacy
and due process. She sued after officials told her not to discuss her same-sex
attraction with students, parents or other staff and denied her a coaching job
because of her sexual orientation. As a
result, the Nebo School District was ordered to pay Weaver morethan $60,000 in
legal fees. Rich Van Wagoner, a Salt
Lake attorney who is working in tandem with the ACLU in Weaver's defense, said
Harding's ruling in regard to the claim by Jeana Barney that her personal and
religious rights were violated by Weaver's presence in a locker room was
problematic. "That is opening up a Pandora's Box or Parade of Horribles or
how ever you want to state it," Van Wagoner said. "Anytime the mere
presence of someone offends someone's rights, you have to start providing
different access to facilities for everybody. . . . It goes right back to
separate but equal." "If I
were in Matt Hilton's shoes, I would not want to be known as the lawyer who resurrected
separate but equal," Van Wagoner said.
25 March 1999 Thursday
I read a sad article about
Greg Hardin being involved in a DUI accident. By STEPHEN HUNT THE SALTLAKE
TRIBUNE WEST VALLEY CITY --
Motorist Greg Brent Hardin had three earlier drunken driving convictions
when he ran a red light last June and slammed into another car while fleeing
police. On Tuesday, Hardin told a 3rd District judge this latest drunken
driving episode was "awake-up call . . . realizing I could kill myself or
another person." Since the crash,
Hardin, 37, says he has remained sober, completed an alcohol treatment program
and started an Alcoholics Anonymous program for people like himself with
AIDS. Judge Ann Boyden said it appeared
Hardin was on the right track, but she ordered 60 days in jail to make sure he
understands the seriousness of his crime. Boyden also ordered Hardin to pay a
$300 fine and more than $19,000 in restitution to the driver he crashed
into. "It's important for me to
hear this was awake-up call," the judge said. "But punishment and
victim compensation are also important."
The crash occurred shortly before midnight on June, 28, 1998 -- only five days after Hardin had been fined and
ordered to do community service for a previous DUI conviction. Hardin had been drinking beer while cruising
near Oxbow Park in South Salt Lake and propositioning men for sex. When police
stopped Hardin for questioning near 1000 West and 3000 South, he ignored
commands to show his hands and sped away with police in pursuit. At the
intersection of 1300 East and 3300 South, Hardin ran a red light and clipped
the front end of a pickup truck driven by Lee Siegel -- a
reporter with The Salt Lake Tribune. Siegel was not seriously injured, but his
vehicle was totaled. Hardin was charged
with third-degree felony failing to respond to police, class A misdemeanor
driving under the influence of alcohol and class C open alcohol container in a
vehicle. Hardin pleaded guilty to reduced misdemeanor charges of attempted
failure to respond and DUI. Corrections
evaluators recommended no jail time for Hardin. But victim Siegel asked
Boyden: "What kind of message is
the state of Utah sending by letting repeated drunken drivers off with slaps on
the wrist? "If you do not sentence
Mr. Hardin to spend time in jail reflecting upon his behavior, I sincerely
believe he will soon drive while intoxicated yet again and eventually kill
someone." Hardin, who was a
lending assistant for First Security Bank, said he received a promotion the day
after the crash. But he later lost his job when his employers learned, from a
Tribune story, that Hardin was carrying bank documents in the car --
including a $98,000 mortgage check. That check and other documents were
strewn across the intersection during the crash.
26 March 1999 Friday
Utah AIDS Foundation Associate
Director Stan Penfold has been named acting executive director of the
foundation, a nonprofit organization that works to prevent the spread of HIV.
He succeeds former Executive Director Barbara Shaw, who has accepted a position
as development director for the Rocky Mountain Conference of the United
Methodist Church.
By Lisa Johnson Moving from
Miami to Salt Lake City can be a culture shock. "Thank God for events like
the AIDS Foundation's Academy Awards party," says KSTU (Ch. 13) news
director Geoff Roth. He had heard about Utah's conservative culture and night
life when here located here three years ago, and wasn't expecting much when he
happened upon this wild gala during his first few months on the Wasatch Front.
"It made me feel much better about my decision," he says. "I
attend this party every year. I wouldn't miss it." It's true there is not an event in March
that rivals this one for sheer surprise and entertainment value. Sure, you can
catch the boys from the local universities gliding across the basketball courts
in sleek uniforms during March Madness, at least for a while. What's not
expected is to see the volunteers with the Utah AIDS Foundation gliding across
a ball room in lame loincloths, painted metallic gold from head to toe,
imitating Oscar himself. The six live Oscars were a nice touch at this year's party,
named "Sunday Matinee" because, for the first time, the awards were
presented on Sunday. But the Oscars
weren't the only changes in this year's festivities at the Double Tree hotel.
For the past two years, the event was at the Utah State Fair park, which was
unavailable to the Utah AIDS Foundation this year. "I think the move was a
good one," says director of development Julie Mayhew. "Even though we
raised the price $10, we had more people this year. I think people like being
uptown." The carpet at the Double
Tree did deter the drag queens on roller skates selling tequila shots. There
wasn't a single one to be found. Instead, the cross-dressing highlight of the
evening was made by Geoffrey Darian, who spent all day with Edith Martin,
decorating the party venue. When the woman who was supposed to wear the Carmen
Miranda costume failed to show up, Darian donned it himself, fruit-basket
headdress and all. Partygoers did a double take when they noticed the Latina
film star of yore had a hairy chest and a mustache. It was all part of the
raucous fun. This year, shot sales were left exclusively to members of the Utah
Gay Rodeo Association, who dressed in full cowboy regalia, with chaps, hats,
kerchiefs and holsters to fit in with the matinee theme. They spent the week
prior whipping up hundreds of Jell-O shooters, pouring them into little
plastic-lidded cups, to be sold for a buck apiece. You had your choice of peach
Jell-O with schnapps, sparkling grape Jell-O with vodka, or this year's new
addition of "Drunken Cherries," marinated in liqueur then dolloped
with whipped cream. All proceeds went directly to the Utah AIDS Foundation. The
Gay Rodeo Association, by the way, is the second largest rodeo association in
the world. Prominent Salt Lake
residents from the straight side of the community were there, many looking
swank in classic tuxedos and elegant ball gowns. But their eagerness to
participate went beyond that. "It's good to see such a large cross-section
of the community here, supporting such a great cause," said architect
Bernardo Flores-Sahagun. The evening included an hors d'oeuvres reception, with
food contributed by the DoubleTree, the Wyndham Hotel, Tuscany, the Marriott
Hotel, Pomodoro, the Little America Hotel and Granato's, all volunteering time
and food for the event. Such competitors teaming together made for a remarkable
repast. There was also a silent auction
with fabulous items like Rosenthall furniture, ski passes, jewelry, a Trevor
Southey limited-edition lithograph framed by the "A" Gallery, and, as
last year, a walk-on part in "Touched by an Angel." Of course, there
was also the sit-down dinner with Cornish game chicks, in dining rooms equipped
with large television screens so guests could watch the broadcast. And, finally,
there was dancing to the music of the Swingorillas. Many members of Utah's Hollywood crowd
gathered at private homes, like people from the cast of "Promised
Land," who intently watched the awards while noshing on Gerald MacRainy's
homemade crawfish gumbo. But over at the DoubleTree, conversation was light and
raucous. One table got into a spirited debate over who is the most beautiful
man in Hollywood. The conversation was spearheaded by Adam Jensen and Robert
Trujillo, first-timers at the event who swear they won't miss it next year.
After eliminating young hunks like Brad Pitt and Ben Affleck, Sean Connery won
the title. Another table was stricken
by the remarkable similarity between Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences
president Jack Valenti and Utah's First Security Bank president Spence Eccles.
Could they be twins separated at birth? several people wondered. At the end of the day, the Utah AIDS
Foundation had surpassed its goal of raising $110,000. “The very next day, I got phone calls from
two companies about reserving corporate tables already for next year, and one
from another woman who said she heard that this benefit was THE place to see
and be seen, so she wanted her name put on the mailing list for next year. "That's a development director's
dream," Mayhew said with a laugh. So if you missed it this year, tickets
are still available for next. Party on.
27 March 1999 Saturday
SALT LAKE RALLY ON SATURDAY TO
CALL FOR LEGAL PROTECTION AGAINSTDISCRIMINATION BY SHAWN FOSTERTHE SALT LAKE
TRIBUNE Many city, state and federal laws protect people from discrimination based
on their race, national origin, religion, gender, disability or political
belief. Missing from that list, say advocates for gays and lesbians, is sexual
orientation. On Saturday, Utahns will
join thousands of others across the nation in urging policymakers to make it
illegal to discriminate against people because of their sexual partners. The
Salt Lake City rally will be held at noon on the state Capitol steps.
"People should be judged on their job performance, not their personal
lives," said Ben Dieterle, one of the organizers of the event. "Gays and
lesbians want to be able to work, do a good job and live their lives without
discrimination. For the average person, it's a no-brainer that sexual
orientation needs to be added to anti-discrimination laws." The issues has been raised before in
Utah.
Last year,
the Salt Lake City Council repealed a month-old city law that protected city
employees from discrimination based on their sexual orientation. And in the past session of the Legislature,
a bill that would have toughened the state's hate-crime law was defeated in
committee. "We cannot treat
groups differently," Sen. Terry Spencer, R-Layton, said at the February
committee hearing. "`This would be a step backwards to classify people . .
. that does a disservice to all of us."
Salt Lake City Councilman Bryce Jolley shared
the sentiment. "Every time we
enumerate another class, we only create more division, “Jolley said Tuesday.
"We should say we don't discriminate period. No one should be
discriminated against."
Dieterle said opponents misunderstand the
issue. "We're not asking for an
affirmative-action program," he said. "We're not asking for any
special consideration. We are recognizing that people are discriminated against
because of sexual orientation, and that it is wrong." Heterosexuals, Dieterle argued, have as
much reason to support this kind of legislation as gays and lesbians. If a gay boss targets an employee because
he or she is straight, the worker should be protected.
"We are still living in a society where
not all people are treated equally," said Jackie Biskupski, a first-term
Democratic state representative who is a lesbian. “The point of the rally is to
say that it is not OK."
Rally at the State Capitol
Steps Saturday, March 27, 1999 at noon As a part of the "Equality Begins
at Home" campaign, Utah will join 49 other states to rally for equal
rights for the gay and lesbian, bisexual and transgendered (GLBT) community.
During the week of March 21-27, tens of thousands of GLBT individuals and their
allies will tell American Legislators that bigotry is un-American. Speakers
include: NGLTF organizer Alexis Sinze,
Dr Thresea Martinez, Professor Deb Burrington,
ACLU Attorney Steve Clark, Debra
Dean, Holly Peterson, Wendy Weaver and others With Special musical guest: Trace
Wiren, Mary Tebbs, and Kathryn Warner
The Gay and Lesbian Political
Action Committee of Utah (GALPAC) and the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force
Invite You to Rally at the State Capitol Steps Saturday, March 27, 1999 at noon
to tell Utah Legislators to ADD US TO THE LIST! Employment Discrimination
cannot continue! As a part of the "Equality Begins at Home" campaign,
Utah will join 49 other states to rally for equal rights for the gay and
lesbian, bisexual and transgendered (GLBT) community. During the week of March
21-27, tens of thousands of GLBT individuals and their allies will tell
American Legislators that bigotry is un-American. Guest speaker include: Dr.
Debra Burrington- Assistant Director Womens Studies Program U of U Charlene
Orchard-Political Organizer Dr. Theresa Martinez-Social Work U of U, and KRCL's
"the voice of the people", Rocky Anderson-Mayoral Candidate, Alexis
Page-NGLTF, Ed Mayne-AFLCIO Jackie Biskuspi-UHR and Possibly Dr. Kathry Stockton-English Dept U 0f U, and
Queer Theorist Paid for by the Gay and Lesbian Political Action Committee of
Utah, anon-partisan, grass roots organization that promotes equality for the
GLBT community of Utah and supports candidates committed to achieving that goal
Gay activists rally at Capitol
in campaign to seek equality Another group protests what it calls propaganda By
Jana McQuay Deseret News staff writer More than 200 gay and lesbian activists
filled the steps of the Utah Capitol Saturday as part of an "Equality
Begins at Home" campaign, which has involved more than 250 similar
demonstrations in 50 states, the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico.
Supporters of the effort have included the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force,
the Gay and Lesbian Political Action Committee and the American Civil Liberties
Union. The campaign began last Sunday and ended Saturday. Spanish Fork High School
teacher Wendy Weaver was among the speakers who talked about discrimination in
the workplace. Weaver recently won a discrimination lawsuit against school
officials. U.S. District Judge Bruce S. Jenkins ruled in favor of Weaver's
constitutional rights of free speech and equal protection. Weaver called
herself an "accidental activist" who fell into national media
attention after being complacent for 17 years as a teacher and volleyball
coach. ACLU attorney Stephen C. Clark continues to represent Weaver in a
lawsuit filed against her by a citizens group in Utah County. Dave Jones, Rocky
Anderson and Jim Bradley, Democratic mayoral candidates for Salt Lake City, all
spoke out against discrimination based on sexual orientation. Jackie Biskupski, the first lesbian
candidate elected to the Utah House from District 30, said she wanted activists
to do more than just sit on the steps of the state Capitol. Biskupski asked
activists to get involved and dedicate their time, energy and finances to win
the battle for equality. Gay activist
Richard Teerlink said he had retired from Kearns High School after 31 years of
employment as a biology and chemistry teacher. He held a poster that read:
"Some of your best teachers are gay." Teerlink said he kept his sexual orientation
quiet until after his retirement in 1997 to protect his career and retirement
benefits. National Gay and Lesbian Task Force field organizer Alexis Sainz said
she was confident that full equality for activists could be achieved in the
next decade. The rally came to a close
with live music performed by Gearl Jam, a local group of singers and
songwriters. During Saturday's rally, the America Forever Foundation protested
across the street against homosexuality "propaganda." The foundation
held a three-day vigil to promote a Youth and Children Human Rights Campaign,
which ended Friday evening. A Utah family founded the America Forever
Foundation last October. PHOTO: Kathy Worthington waves a flag during the
gay-rights rally at Capitol.
Reconciliation held a Line
Dancing Lessons and Party upstairs at the
Center. The Wasatch Mountain Bears had a Video Party at Pete and Blair's 1764 S 600 E
28 March 1999 Sunday
Gay and Lesbian Political
Action Committee (GALPAC) 1-3 pm upstairs at the Center
Wasatch Affirmation held pot
luck social at Gary and Milly Watts' home in Provo
29 March 1999
Monday
The GLCCU held a Meeting of
the Community Forum at the Center Each organization is invited to send at least
one representative to the meeting
Individuals are invited to join the Forum as well
The Wasatch
Mountain Bears played Cards at the Center 730pm
30 March 1999 Tuesday
There was a Gay Single Men's
Mixer held 7pm at the Stonewall Coffee Shop at the Center. “ Conversation,
Cards, Videos "Will and Grace" I went without Mike Romero even though
technically I wasn’t single just to get out and try to see what is happening
with Gays in the community. It wasn’t much of a mixer as most guys were with
their friends they came with or were sitting alone. It wasn’t organized at all
and most guys there were in their 20’s it seemed. I was out of place for sure
so I just perused what is left of the Stonewall Library and ordered a cup of coffee.
I read a copy of the April edition of the Pillar that was out already.
I read in the
newspaper that Lucille Ball’s second husband Gary Morton died at the age of 71.
I didn’t know he was so much younger that her.
Utah Chronicle Rallying
Respect Community Members Work to Gain
Equality for People of Every Sexual Orientation Kathryn Cowles Chronicle Feature
Writer THE WIND ON THE STEPS of the State Capitol Saturday whipped over
hand-painted signs and rainbow diversity flags alike, meanwhile tousling hair
of all colors and types. We were close to freezing. Any civil rights crusader
would have been proud. As the crowd turned around mid-rally for pictures from
the various newspapers and members of the press, I was overwhelmed with a great
sense of the interconnectedness of the multiple issues and causes this group represented. In fact, one point highly
emphasized at the Rally for Employment Non-Discrimination for the gay, lesbian,
bisexual and transgendered community was the idea that all people who do not
have equal opportunities, whether based on sex, race, religion, sexuality,
social class, physical disability, age or any other reason, are fighting the
same battle. Teresa Martinez, a sociology professor (also cross-listed in
Women's Studies) at the University of Utah and a speaker at the rally, said,
"These are human issues. They're not some other people in some other
place. They're our issues, and we are all connected to each other." The Employment Non-Discrimination Rally was
organized by the Gay and Lesbian Political Action Committee and the National Gay and Lesbian
Task Force in cooperation with the American Civil Liberties Union of Utah. This
rally was one of 350 similar demonstrations connected with the nationwide "Equality Begins at Home"
project. Because many civil rights
issues are decided locally by city and state government officials, the "Equality
Begins at Home" project focuses on legislation at the state level. As
Alexis Sáinz of the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force put it, local
communities must work together "for equality in the workplace, at home, in
our schools and in these very streets" because "the things that
affect us on a daily basis are being decided right here." Central speakers in the Rally for Employment
Non-Discrimination were those who have been forced to fight, sometimes with a
high media profile, for their own individual employment (and other) rights.
Holly Peterson, a former student of East High and member of East's Gay-Strait
Alliance, explained what happened to her when the management of a restaurant
where she was employed found out she was a lesbian. They asked Peterson
questions about her bumper stickers, her social life and her roommate, among
other things. "They asked me to be more professionally feminine," she
said. Peterson was asked to wear skirts and makeup, despite the fact that this
was not required in the dress code (slacks and a shirt) when she was hired,
before her sexuality became common knowledge.
Later, Peterson was fired from her job, presumably on the basis of her
sexual orientation. "I have never been fired before," Peterson said.
"Job security needs to be mandated," she said, because the threat of
being fired on the basis of sexuality is real. Peterson hopes to find a
political realm where, in her words, "I won't be fired for who I am."
Represented among the many speakers at Saturday's Rally were three Salt Lake
City mayoral candidates. The presence of these candidates was a sign that the
GLBT community is recognized as a voting power.
The first mayoral candidate to speak was Rocky Anderson. "No one
ever explains,"
said Anderson, "how special rights arise from simply guaranteeing gays and lesbians the same
rights that everyone else enjoys." Anderson said he wants "legal protection
for gays and lesbians," noting that pro-gay legislation not only supports gays and lesbians legally,
it also "sends a message far beyond the political arena"
that unequal treatment of the gay community in general will not be tolerated. Jim Bradley, another candidate, commented on
what the presence of three mayoral candidates as speakers at the rally meant.
The fact that the necessity of equal rights among all citizens, regardless of
their differences, was recognized by all three candidates seemed to Bradley to
be a sign of a hopeful future in the way of civil rights. After all, Bradley
claimed, it is the duty of a politician to "bring communities together and
to accept, and in fact celebrate, diversity." A third mayoral candidate, Dave Jones,
focused his speech on how astounding it
is to him that our state, even our country, is still debating whether certain
groups deserve basic human rights. Jones claimed that because of politically active members of the GLBT community,
politicians are "having to deal with" issues of homosexuality.
"You are the people," he said to the crowd, "who are leading the
change" in favor of civil rights. "My hat is off to you." Many
members of the crowd seemed shocked, in the best sense of the word, at the
positive and supportive statements these politicians had for the pro-gay
citizens at the rally. Steve Clark, an attorney and member of the ACLU of Utah,
spoke concerning discrimination in the workplace, pointing out that progress
has been made overall in the movement for equality with "one glaring
exception:" the GLBT community. Clark represents Wendy Weaver in what he
says has been called "the most important case for the rights of gay and
lesbian teachers in the country." Weaver was the concluding speaker at the
rally. She deemed herself an "accidental activist" in that she
thought her successful teaching and volleyball coaching in the Nebo School
District would "outweigh the fact of who [she] was living with,"
rather than necessitate a fight to keep her own teaching position safe. "I
was wrong," she said. Weaver's coaching job was discontinued on the basis
of her sexuality. She was even asked not to discuss her sexuality or home life
with anyone, including co-workers. The crowd did take a rather moral beating
from a number of speakers upset by the lack of political involvement from much
of the pro-gay community. Jackie Biskupski,
the first openly gay member of the Utah State Legislature, chided those in the
crowd who were not politically involved. Biskupski said it took a group of East
High School kids fighting for a Gay-Strait Alliance to make her realize how
important it is to get involved “Change," Biskupski said, is "only
going to come about when you take risks, when you're willing to fight a hard
battle, like Wendy [Weaver], when you're willing to say 'enough is
enough.'" Biskupski challenged members of the pro-gay community to
"leave here today making a commitment to yourself that if you are going to
demand equality, you must also demand from yourself time" in the form of a
commitment, financially and otherwise, to personally help turn into a fact.
University of Utah professor of women's studies Deb Burrington encouraged the
crowd to "turn the light on in our own closets." Burrington said the
debilitating prejudices within the GLBT community itself, and at times the lack
of support for one another, disables the cause as a whole. "The struggle
for liberation," Burrington stated, "must be a collective and
inclusive event." Among the groups sometimes disowned by some members of
the gay community are those who are labeled "transgendered," or
"transsexual." Burrington criticized those of the pro-gay community
who drop these and other fringe groups. This is, she said, just another form of
"internalized homophobia." Members of the transgendered community
were in fact represented among the speakers at the rally. Nicole Cline of the
Western Transsexual Network spoke of "challenging some of the traditional
thoughts society has that are so stereotypical of what we, in this community,
are." Cline said the "government is accountable to us, 'We the
People.'" Debra Dean, founder of Engendered Species, addressed local
prejudices against the transgendered community. "All the world seems
welcome here," she said, "but maybe not us."
31 March 1999 Wednesday
There was second blue moon this year tonight which is
extremely rarely to have two in the same year. It won’t happen again in 10
years and by then I will be dead. This was my love song for Billy Bikowski’s
unrequited love for me “If I miss you at all ... it's just now and then Just
once ... in a very blue moon And I feel one comin' on soon…There's a blue moon
shinin' When I am reminded of all we've been through…Such a blue moon ...
shinin' Does it ever shine down on you? You act as if it never hurt you at all Like
I'm the only one who's gettin' up from a fall Don't you remember? Can't you
recall?” I don’t know how many night I wept over Billy.
Planned Parenthood came to the Center and presented a
Women's Health Lecture with a discussion focusing on Lesbian Health Issues.
No comments:
Post a Comment